Brownie, In an e-mail on the 29th of Oct. in which you wrote to the Younger-L it says: Judy Foley writes: Belle Starr was from my line because she married into the Youngers. She married Bruce Younger and lived with him for two years. No issue. I didn't say that! Go back and read what I wrote. I was discussing the Shirley family that my g grandfather's people were from. I said my Shirley line was not the same as Belle Star's because I had looked it up. She is on the Valentine Shirley line and mine is the Moses Shirley line. I know in the paragraph I wrote, the words" Belle Starr was from my line", did not come from my mouth. Do you all just take things and interpret them the way you want to? Techinally, I guess because my gr. grandmother was a cousin of the whole Younger group, I guess you can interpret it, that I would then be related to her in some way. But not from my Shirley side.