Since you have the other D2 Isles raw data, you can see first hand the clash between you two. Looking at all 9 I can only add: Everyone is CC- for PF6143 except Woods who shows AA+ PF2642 is a misbehaving snp, showing AA for a I1 person, GG- for most everyone, but AG for Woods. How about S7725? Are you in agreement with Woods on that snp? Kenneth Nordtvedt Haplogroup I Clade Modalities and Trees at: http://knordtvedt.home.bresnan.net -----Original Message----- From: John O'Grady Sent: Saturday, January 11, 2014 9:52 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: [yDNAhgI] Chromo2 and Hg I Ken, Full Genomes says that I am PF2642=T+ and PF6143=G-. John O'Grady ------------------------------- To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to [email protected] with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message

Full Genomes doesn't cover the high S SNPs such as S7725, because Wilson hasn't published the positions. My G- for PF6143 agrees with the majority CC- (reverse strand), so PF6143 could split Isles-D. My T+ for PF2642 matches AA+ (reverse strand). I guess we will have to wait for more results. John O'Grady ---------------------------------------- > > Since you have the other D2 Isles raw data, you can see first hand the clash > between you two. Looking at all 9 I can only add: > > Everyone is CC- for PF6143 except Woods who shows AA+ > > PF2642 is a misbehaving snp, showing AA for a I1 person, GG- for most > everyone, but AG for Woods. > > How about S7725? Are you in agreement with Woods on that snp? > > Kenneth Nordtvedt

PF6143 is in a span of PF numbers (PF5998 to PF6150, corrected) which I reported yesterday to contain many apparent errors as to the ancestral and/or derived values. However, PF6143 (also known as M778) is one of the few correctly reported SNPs in this region, and its G to T (C to A reverse strand) values agree with my Full Genomes result (G-) at position 21499869 of the Y. The ISOGG Y Browser reports it occurred somewhere in Haplogroup R, so a T result in I2, if correct, would represent a second occurrence. PF2642 (C to T, or G to A reverse strand) is reported by the Y Browser to be at the level of FK in the Y Tree, so everyone in I should be derived unless a back mutation has occurred. Full Genomes also reports my PF2642 result as T+. On Sat, Jan 11, 2014 at 11:37 AM, John O'Grady <[email protected]>wrote: > Full Genomes doesn't cover the high S SNPs such as S7725, because Wilson > hasn't published the positions. > > My G- for PF6143 agrees with the majority CC- (reverse strand), so PF6143 > could split Isles-D. > > My T+ for PF2642 matches AA+ (reverse strand). I guess we will have to > wait for more results. > > John O'Grady > >