Dear List, While analyzing the WTY score for kit# 150778 on Finch2, I found at least a couple SNP's, which were not highlighted in the results but that seem promising to the M223+ community. The individual mentioned above tested positive for these SNP's, whereas other M223+ WTY participants tested negative for them. They are: L319 - positive in Roots WTY participant (kit# 150778, L812+), negative in two other M223 WTY participants (kit#s 31781, L623+/L147.4+ and 69631, L801+) - and presumably negative for kit# 95338 (Roots). L380 - positive in Roots WTY participant (kit# 150778, L812+), negative in M223 WTY participant kit# 31781 (L623+/L147.4+) - presumably negative for kit# 69631 ( L801+), not covered in WTY of kit# 95338 (Roots). The reason these SNP's were not highlighted in the WTY results for kit# 150778 is unknown. WTY scores should be reviewed by haplogroup project administrators - with each + result being individually compared to all other WTY participants from a given haplogroup. Aaron Torres

I suspect the reason they are not highlighted is that they were not "discoveries" in the test subject; they had been "discovered" elsewhere in the tree in other earlier tests. That does not diminish their potential usefulness, however. -----Original Message----- From: Aaron Salles Torres Sent: Sunday, November 13, 2011 9:35 AM To: ISOGG@yahoogroups.com ; genealogy-dna@rootsweb.com ; y-dna-haplogroup-i@rootsweb.com Subject: [yDNAhgI] SNP's overlooked in WTY? Dear List, While analyzing the WTY score for kit# 150778 on Finch2, I found at least a couple SNP's, which were not highlighted in the results but that seem promising to the M223+ community. The individual mentioned above tested positive for these SNP's, whereas other M223+ WTY participants tested negative for them. They are: L319 - positive in Roots WTY participant (kit# 150778, L812+), negative in two other M223 WTY participants (kit#s 31781, L623+/L147.4+ and 69631, L801+) - and presumably negative for kit# 95338 (Roots). L380 - positive in Roots WTY participant (kit# 150778, L812+), negative in M223 WTY participant kit# 31781 (L623+/L147.4+) - presumably negative for kit# 69631 ( L801+), not covered in WTY of kit# 95338 (Roots). The reason these SNP's were not highlighted in the WTY results for kit# 150778 is unknown. WTY scores should be reviewed by haplogroup project administrators - with each + result being individually compared to all other WTY participants from a given haplogroup. Aaron Torres ------------------------------- To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to Y-DNA-HAPLOGROUP-I-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message

Aaron, I read the WTY chromats on Finch2. Kit 95338 is L319-. Kit 69631 is L380+. John O'Grady > Date: Sun, 13 Nov 2011 08:35:26 -0800 > From: sallfertorr@yahoo.com > To: ISOGG@yahoogroups.com; genealogy-dna@rootsweb.com; y-dna-haplogroup-i@rootsweb.com > Subject: [yDNAhgI] SNP's overlooked in WTY? > > Dear List, > > While analyzing the WTY score for kit# 150778 on Finch2, I found at least a couple SNP's, which were not highlighted in the results but that seem promising to the M223+ community. The individual mentioned above tested positive for these SNP's, whereas other M223+ WTY participants tested negative for them. They are: > > L319 - positive in Roots WTY participant (kit# 150778, L812+), negative in two other M223 WTY participants (kit#s 31781, L623+/L147.4+ and 69631, L801+) - and presumably negative for kit# 95338 (Roots). > > L380 - positive in Roots > WTY participant (kit# 150778, L812+), negative in M223 WTY participant kit# 31781 (L623+/L147.4+) - presumably negative for kit# 69631 ( L801+), not covered in WTY of kit# 95338 (Roots). > > The reason these SNP's were not > highlighted in the WTY results for kit# 150778 is unknown. WTY scores should be reviewed by haplogroup project administrators - with each + result being individually compared to all other WTY participants from a given haplogroup. > > Aaron Torres

-----Original Message----- From: John O'Grady Sent: Sunday, November 13, 2011 2:33 PM To: y-dna-haplogroup-i@rootsweb.com ; genealogy-dna@rootsweb.com Subject: Re: [DNA] [yDNAhgI] SNP's overlooked in WTY? Aaron, I read the WTY chromats on Finch2. Kit 95338 is L319-. Kit 69631 is L380+. [[This is getting interesting. L380+ is being called derived for two I1d, negative for 7 I1xL22, negative in I2*, negative in M26+ and Dinaric, negative in a L623+ part of M223+ I wonder if there was a switch in the calling rule for derived at some point in the lab? Is A+ derived in all instances? KN ]]