Nancy what chart are you looking at??? post a descendancy quick and dirty for those generations with ??? I think(big mistake) it is getting confused in the question somehow. In a message dated 10/5/2010 10:28:28 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, nlrawlings@gmail.com writes: Lots of information going out today, so I have a question. On the chart, the children of Sidney Chew and Charles Pierpoint are shown as Charles Pierpoint and Francis Pierpoint. As work goes forward on next year's reunion, are you considering Chew Pierpoint who married Basel Deaver as a valid child of Sidney Chew and Charles Pierpoint? Since that's my line, I need to know before I start sending Joe what I have on my line. Cuz Connie