On January 14, Carol wrote: "John, What is your connection to Norban (also noted as Norman) and Elizabeth Duncan? Norban was a brother to J(ohn) Walter Duncan who married my great aunt Virginia Bowles. Below is the obit for the father of Norban and Walter, John Hunter Duncan. Carol" Hi Carol - Norban was the brother of Thomas Edgar Duncan who married my great aunt Rosa E. Cox, in Summers County, WV on November 12, 1901. Thanks for the obit - Back in February last year I got that obit off the Summers site - were you the one that posted it? - at that time I thought but was not sure that he was the father of my Thomas. Having researched the census on Ancestry and West Virginia Vital Research Records the past three days I finally made the connection - also, by death records I associated Norban as being married to Elizabeth Ann Nedrick - is this incorrect? Would like to share information with you - my email address is: [email protected] John Cox in South Dakota