This is a Message Board Post that is gatewayed to this mailing list. Classification: Query Message Board URL: http://boards.ancestry.com/mbexec/msg/rw/IEC.2ACE/1142 Message Board Post: Elder Samuel had son John, died young. John Arnold who married Susan Shaffer, decended from William I. and Elizabeth Sharp Arnold. Johan George and Anna Maria Barth Arnold, had at least four sons: John, Daniel, Samuel and Andrew. Samuel (1728) married Elizabeth Lehn. He died 1808 in Adams Co, PA. I do not have his descendants. We know about John and Margaret Albaugh Arnold's descendants. Daniel married Agnes Stoner, lived in Brother's Valley PA. I have no descendants. Andrew married Catherine Stoner. They had Rebecca, Abraham, David, Joseph, Jacob, Hannah, Susannah, John, Daniel, Samuel (Not Elder Samuel of Beaver Run) I need from whom William I. Arnold descended. Some family historian needs to do family history on Samuel(b:1728) and Daniel of Brother's Valley, and we may solve the mystery . I am descended from both William I Arnold, and Beaver Run-Elder Samuel. Rosalie