Hi Christina, Harrison should be in the 1850 Preston Co. WV He was born July 1849 in WV according to the 1900 Preston Co. WV census. I checked the 1850 census but couldn't find him. Maybe I need to go back and check again which will take time as I have it on disk. Do you have him on any Census with the Frankhouser's? Maybe 1860 or 1870? Maybe they didn't have him as a Goodwin/Gooding but a Frankhouser, maybe that's why I missed him. I have Hannah in the 1880 Preston Co. census without Harrison, but it says she is married so maybe he was off working someplace, maybe Fayette Co., PA and didn't list him. I think Monday I will call the Preston Co. Courthouse and see if they have a death record of 1923 on him since there isn't any in the WV State Archives on Line, maybe they missed him. Thanks so much for you help. Regards Delores (Mollohan) Hartman daughter of Phame Olive Goodwin b. in Bruceton Mills, WV.