In a message dated 5/18/99 9:19:36 AM Mountain Daylight Time, [email protected] writes: << Cynthia Lively(1843-1874-T.B.) married Edward Arthur-1863.When Cynthia died her baby ,Edna May,went to live with her grandparent Livelys As i understand it Cynthia is the d/o Gordon Lively (1-1-1810-1-11-1876)& Frances Maddy or Jordan Lively & Cynthia Ballengee >> I don't have "Cynthia" in my db, but wonder if she could be listed as "Sidney?" Monroe County, West Virginia - 1850 Census by Louise Perkins Page 5 68/68 LIVELY Jourden 40 Fa VA Cinthia 41 Page 6 68/68 LIVELY cont'd Susan J. 16 Mary F. 14 Vincent J. 13 Martha A. 11 Lewis W. 8 f Sidney 7 <----Cynthia? Caleb 4 Victoria 2 CD229 Marriage Index: KY, NC, TN, VA, WV, 1728-1850 Monroe Co., (W)VA Lively, Jordan Spouse : Belenger, Synthia Marriage date : 17 Jan 1833 By the way, I have Frances MADDY as the mother of Jordan LIVELY. I show Frances MADDY as married to Joseph LIVELY, brother of Cottrell LIVELY. Is this incorrect?