Sandy of Florida, Thanks again for the information on Goodall Garten and Sarah Robinson's marriage. Sarah was the daughter of James Robinson and Sarah Hurt. Sarah is living with her mother Sarah Robinson in the 1860 and 1870 Monroe census. James and Sarah married in Bedford County, VA Oct 13, 1843. She was the daughter of John Hurt and Polly Chaffin. Their marriage was also in Bedford. Sue of Craig County