Hi Jack, This Lovina "Boyce" appears to be a different one than in the 1860 VA, possibly the daughter of Lavina and James listed in the 1860 as Melvina (age 18)??? Anyway, here is the info from the 1870C: 1870 / WV / Doddridge Co / McClellan Twp / Roll M593_1686, page 38 / West Union PO / lines 28-32 / Household #s: 183/156 SWIGER - all white Wesley L, male, age 27, farmer, b VA Lovina, female, age 27, keeping house, b VA, cannot write Albert N G, male, age 6, attends school, b WV William P, male, age 3, b WV Felix D, male, age 3 mo. b Aug in WV Katie