While checking more than one source I came up with this. The age right: 1910 PA census Joseph S Clifford Age: 33 State: PA Color: W Enumeration District: 0596 Birth Place: West Virginia County: Allegheny, Pittsburgh Relation: Son Other Residents: Head of Household Mary Lannon 53 WV Could it be that the father is deceased and the mother remarried? 1910 KY John H Clifford Enumeration District: 0099 Color: W Age: 30 Birth Place: Kentucky Visit: 0128 County: Rockcastle Relation: Husband Relatives: Wife Maudy 35, Kentucky Daughter Ersie 15, Kentucky Daughter Iva 12, Kentucky Son Stephen 10, Kentucky Niece Julia M NR, Kentucky Many times relatives went to other states to work. Semper Fi Mary Ann Home page: http://members.home.net/merrittone/ Reunion 2002 researching Eastern Ky aand WV Family Trees http://groups.yahoo.com/group/JOCOKYReunion2002 Johnson Co. Ky ACC http://www.rootsweb.com/~kyjohnso/jcindex.htm