Dear Sue, I found your letter most interesting and thank you for all the information given. Your name also caught my eye as my VIVIAN cousin was looking for the name Mackie in 1881 recently, expecting them in Scotland and finding them in Carmarthenshire!The list of offspring also showed the parents wanderings! I think I know why some replies are off line. I have found that if you hit the reply button for some lists you just get the original writer's name. I usually put in the list name afterwards as I am doing here. I have found American 3rd cousins researching BATH/COLLIER names in Somerset and Glamorgan/MON border have been very helpful...but we still have gaps so I'll try your ideas. Many thanks Jane in Canada