This is a Message Board Post that is gatewayed to this mailing list. Classification: Query Message Board URL: http://boards.ancestry.com/mbexec/msg/rw/CGC.2ACI/516 Message Board Post: PHILENA ANNIS - JOHN R BENEDICT. Philena was a daughter of Thomas & MArtha, McClary) Annis. IN 1850 they lived in HAmburg, erie Co., NY then went to OMRO, WI near Oshkosh, WI 1870 US Federal Census (Pg 209B) Oshkosh, Winnebago Co, WI Ward 1 Recorded - June 6, 1870 Benedict, John R. - 67 yrs - NY - Farmer (wife) Philena M. - 53 yrs - VT (son) Robert M. - 26 yrs - NY - Laborer (son) Daniel - 22 yrs - NY - Student at Law (son) John R. Jr - 17 yrs - NY - Door Factory (daut) Rosetta M. - 13 yrs - WI (daut) Sarah J. - 7 yrs - WI Childs, Alfred - 21 yrs - VT - Laborer Then in 1910, John R. Benedict aged 56 yrs old and this could be John Jr? 1910 US Federal Census (Pg 108A) Grand Rapids, Kent Co, MI E.D. 63, Ward 3 Recorded - April 28, 1910 Benedict, John R. - 56 yrs - NY - Cabinet Maker Factory (wife) Libbie - 55 yrs - IN - O Children - Married 35 yrs Post Reply | Mark Unread | Report Abuse