Does anyone have any further information about Charles Whitney, born 21 July 1823, to Edward and Rhoda Whitney in Athol, MA? According to the 1900 Federal Census for Erie Co, NY, my Charles Whitney was born in Jul 1823 in Massachusetts. So far, Charles of Athol is the closest match I've found. The earliest record I've found for my Charles is a 1856 land purchase in Putnam Co, OH. The property was sold in 1864 and they appear in Erie Co, NY on the 1865 NYS census. Thanks in advance, Debbie