Dear Ruby and Jackie, You have the love and respect of all of us. We are all very thankful for the hours of work you have put into helping so many of us. I have found your work to be very accurate..even to having supplied me with the correct birth and death dates of a remote Whaley I was searching. Its unbelieveable that this person would slander your names and good reputation. They are perhaps very disturbed over something and I think we should all just pray for them. Maybe the person needs a lot of help...from God. I have never seen such bitterness. Continue on with your great work, please! You have the support and respect of so many serious researcher and Whaley lines. I'm sure all of us love you for what you are doing for you and appreciate it deeply. Samuel Whaley and Patience H. line Mary Kinch of Jackson, MI