Dear Monika Butler, For brevity, may I call you Monika ? I am a great grandson of Caroline and her husband Thomas George Westall of St. Lucia. Their son Ernest George Westall of Halifax, N.S., Canada is my grandfather. I am aware of info you provided regarding Caroline Agatha Hutchinson (Westall) to Bob Westall 23 Nov 2006 (re rootsweb). She is my great grandmother and I am trying to reconcile some different records regarding her name. You identified her also as Caroline Agatha Hutchinson and her sister as Louisa Catherine Hutchinson born in India in 1859. Questions: Can you possibly explain why Thomas George Westall (her fathers Will, ref attached notes ) says she was born a Hinkson ? Strangely the will initially identifies her as Caroline Agatha Hutchinson Westall and a co executrice & befactor. Was Caroline also born in India ? How are you related to or associated with Caroline to be so familiar with the family history ? I would welcome the opportunity to exchange any information with you. Thank you, respectfully, Tom Joyce Waterloo, Ontario, Canada 519.885.4714