Hi Maureen, Many thanks for coming back to me. Thank you very much for looking at the 1851 census for me. I think I have now found him in Norfolk. I have a Peter MILNER in my tree who married Dorothy Margaret ALDOUS in the mid 20th century. Best wishes, Paul Hi Paul, good of you to let me know you may have found ROBERT. My MILNERs came from Thorpe Willoughby in Yorkshire. Most stayed in around the village but one son moved to Brotherton & two to Pontefract mid/late 1800's (all very close to Knottingley) Where did your PETER come from? good luck, Maureen Pontefract Liquorice Festival 7th - 15th July _http://www.pontefractliquoricefestival.co.uk/_ (http://www.pontefractliquoricefestival.co.uk/)