I think this is may be who you are looking for. Clara had a brother Levie and I bet whoever gave the death info remembered incorrectly. This is the 1880 census. Ruth Cherecwich Census Place: Cotton, Switzerland, Indiana Source: FHL Film 1254313 National Archives Film T9-0313 Page 14A Relation Sex Marr Race Age Birthplace Nelson BARTON Self M M W 45 IN Occ: Farmer Fa: OH Mo: IN Lydia BARTON Wife F M W 38 IN Occ: Keeping House Fa: IN Mo: IN Franklin BARTON Son M S W 18 IN Occ: Farm Hand Fa: IN Mo: IN Clara BARTON Dau F S W 14 IN Occ: Keeping House Fa: IN Mo: IN Levie BARTON Son M S W 13 IN Occ: At Home Fa: IN Mo: IN Bertha BARTON Dau F S W 11 IN Fa: IN Mo: IN Benjamin BARTON Son M S W 10 IN Fa: IN Mo: IN