I have a baptismal cert of my gr. aunt bapt at St. Nicholas in CarrickOnSuir. In the book"Carrick-On-Suir and its people" by P.C.Power published in 1976-Anna Livia Books - there is a picture of the "Old" St. Nicholas which was replaced by the present St Nicholas in 1879. I hope this clears up the St. Nicholas Church question. Frank Fitzgerald