I'm searching for the grandparents of Benjamin Harrison Rose b 08-08-1892 d 09-23-1952 Dickenson County VA. He was the son of Frank (aka Ned) Rose b approx 1874 by Mary Ann Dutton b approx 2/1878 Marrage 7/19/1888. "Ned" had a younger brother William J (aka Jeems) Rose b approx 1879 who married Mary Ann's sister Sarah Jane (aka Jane) Dutton. Sometime after 1892 Jeems shot and killed his brother Ned. Because of similarity of names in the Rose line, I'm unable to determine the parentage of these two brothers. I believe it to be a Franklin Edward who would be born circa 1850-1865. The two marriages lists Jane Dutton born in Ky. and Mary Dutton born in Virginia. The Duttons were from the Martin-Lawrence County Kentucky area and moved back and forth for a while before settling down in South of the Mountain area of Wise County which later became Dickenson County. Any help would be much appreciated. ALSO, pls do not confuse with Frank Rose who married a Sarah or Sally. Thanks! Angelee