David N. Murray, I think I found your man! Patrick Murray, age 25, born Ireland, listed on 1870 Census Index for Warren Co VA, Front Royal P. O., Micro Film Roll #1680 page 437 Source: Family Tree Maker's Family Archives Census Index: Virginia & West Virginia, 1870 on CD 290. I hope you can get the Micro Film and get additional information. Good luck. Nettie S. Clifton, nettie@erols.com