According to information posted on Crockett Duncan, his wife was Mary Ellen Duncan -daughter of Beauford Duncan 1831-1905 and Sarah Elizabeth Simmons 1838 -1907 According to the marriage registration of their daughter Lillie Alice to William Barton Smith, Lillie Alices' mother was Ellie Hawley. Later census show his wife as Mary E Duncan, but Ellie could a nickname for Ellen. Beauford and Sarah did have a daughter named Mary E. but is this Crocketts wife or is a Mary Ellen "Ellie" Hawley his wife as indicated on the marriage registration?