Vicky, Could the third Hugh Caldwell listed be your man? My notes say most of this information came from the Austin book so I'm not sure how reliable it is. Lee Eakin Descendants of Hugh Caldwell 1 Hugh Caldwell d: Unknown . +Rutha (NMN) Caldwell d: Unknown ........ 2 Stephen Caldwell d: Unknown ........ 2 Hugh Caldwell d: Unknown .................. 3 James Caldwell b: 1790 d: 29 May 1869 in Craig County, Virginia ...................... +Jane Caldwell Weirs m: 11 June 1818 d: Unknown ............................ 4 Fleming B. Caldwell d: Unknown ............................ 4 Jane Caldwell b: 1820 d: Unknown ................................ +Henry Reynolds b: 1815 d: Unknown ............................ 4 William Harvey Caldwell b: 1826 d: 1863 ................................ +Mariah Frances Craft b: 1834 d: 1916 Father: Benjamin Craft Mother: Sarah (Sally) (NMN) Craft ...................................... 5 Fleming B. Caldwell d: Unknown ...................................... 5 Amanda Caldwell b: 1851 d: Unknown ...................................... 5 John Wilkie Caldwell b: 1852 d: 1930 ...................................... 5 Mariah Louise Caldwell b: 14 November 1853 d: 24 June 1913 .......................................... +John Josiah EAKIN b: 25 November 1836, Botetourt Co., VA m: 28 July 1869 d: Unknown Father: Samuel Eakin Mother: Eleanor Champ ...................................... 5 Harvey Lewis Caldwell b: 1856 d: Unknown ...................................... 5 James H. Caldwell b: 1858 d: Unknown ...................................... 5 Sarah Jane Caldwell b: 1860 d: Unknown ...................................... 5 Elisha William Caldwell b: 1862 d: Unknown ............................ 4 HUGH N. CALDWELL b: 1834 d: Unknown ............................ 4 Matilda Caldwell b: 1850 d: Unknown .................. *2nd Wife of James Caldwell: ...................... +Celia Damewood m: 28 January 1844 ............................ 4 James Hilary Caldwell d: Unknown ............................ 4 Mary Caldwell b: 1846 d: Unknown ............................ 4 Miles Thomas Caldwell b: 1847 d: 1865 in Point Lookout ............................ 4 Newton Caldwell b: 12 December 1848 d: 10 October 1920 ........ 2 Elizabeth Caldwell d: Unknown ........ 2 Margaret Caldwell d: Unknown ........ 2 Mary Caldwell d: Unknown ........ 2 Eunice Caldwell d: Unknown ........ 2 Rutha Caldwell d: Unknown