I was all wrong about Paulina NOFFSINGER likely being Paulina CRAWFORD. The two women were married to different men at the same time! But I did get data given to me and from my own searches. Here it is: 1850 Botetourt County VA Census: Noftzinger Samuel 47 M Farmer 9,492 Virginia Noftzinger Lucy 42 F Virginia Noftzinger Elizabeth 18 F Virginia Noftzinger Jane 16 F Virginia Noftzinger Margaret 14 F Virginia Noftzinger Martin 12 M Virginia Noftzinger Charles 10 M Virginia Noftzinger Penelope 8 F Virginia Noftzinger Isabella 7 F Virginia Noftzinger Samuel 5 M Virginia Noftzinger Emma 3 F Virginia Noftzinger Pauline 1 F Virginia Wilshire James 18 M Laborer Virginia The image of the above actually does not say Pauline, but it says Paulina.- VES. 1860 Botetourt County VA Census: Samuel NOFFSINGER 57 M Tenant ? Lucy 53 F Panelopa 17 F Isabella 15 F Samuel 13 M E 12 F Paulina 11 F Robt CALINDA? 21 M Shoemaker 1870 - Not known at this time. 1880 Buchanan, Botetourt VA Census: Lina E KING Self M Female W 30 VA Keeping House VA VA Lilly M KING Dau S Female W 9 VA VA VA Clara J KING Dau S Female W 7 VA VA VA Lucy B KING Dau S Female W 6 VA VA VA Annie G KING Dau S Female W 2 VA VA VA Willie D KING Son S Male W 4M VA VA VA Buchanan, Botetourt, Virginia 1255356 T9-1356 109B I imagine the actual census image would indicate whether of Not Paulina is widowed in 1880. Here is where Paulina's mother Lucy Fleagar Noffsinger wound up in 1880: James B. ZIMMERMAN Self M Male W 34 VA Farmer VA VA Emma ZIMMERMAN Wife M Female W 32 VA Keeping House VA VA Rufus T. ZIMMERMAN Son S Male W 3 VA VA VA Mable ZIMMERMAN Dau S Female W 2 VA VA VA Lewis ZIMMERMAN Son S Male W 1 VA VA VA Lucy NOFSINGER MotherL W Female W 73 VA Keeping House VA VA Robert BANISTER Other S Male B 7 VA VA VA Fincastle, Botetourt, Virginia 1255356 T9-1356 84C Vince Summers