Hi Vicky, My Susannah Beckner married William Obenshain. I also have her listed as marrying one of the older William Obenshain's in the family. This is the information that I have. Hope you can clear up the myster for me. Thanks!! Lynda Murphy 1. SUSANNAH2 BECKNER (DANIEL1) was born November 18, 1813 in Botetourt County, Virginia, and died September 22, 1874 in Botetourt County, Virginia. She married WILLIAM OBENSHAIN March 24, 1831, son of DANIEL OBENSHAIN and HANNAH MARQUART. Children of SUSANNAH BECKNER and WILLIAM OBENSHAIN are: i. WILLIAM M.3 OBENSHAIN, b. April 19, 1848; d. WFT Est. 1849-1938; Stepchild. 2. ii. CARY BRACKINRIDGE OBENSHAIN, b. June 14, 1835, Virginia; d. WFT Est. 1850-1923. iii. DANIEL R. OBENSHAIN, b. February 19, 1832; d. October 13, 1862, Botetourt County, Virginia; m. ARLONA NASH, WFT Est. 1849-1882. iv. AMANDA OBENSHAIN, b. February 08, 1835; d. WFT Est. 1849-1929; m. JAMES FERGUSON, WFT Est. 1849-1882. v. AMERICA OBENSHAIN, b. December 17, 1840; d. WFT Est. 1854-1934; m. JOHN LAKES, WFT Est. 1854-1887. 3. vi. AGATHA BOYER OBENSHAIN, b. July 06, 1842; d. January 19, 1880, Bedford County, Virginia. vii. CHRISTIANNA OBENSHAIN, b. September 14, 1845; d. WFT Est. 1859-1939; m. LUTHER PEARSEY, WFT Est. 1859-1892. viii. ELLEN J. OBENSHAIN, b. June 19, 1846; d. WFT Est. 1847-1940. ix. JAMES M. OBENSHAIN, b. April 19, 1848; d. WFT Est. 1849-1938. x. CHARLES HARVEY OBENSHAIN, b. April 08, 1849; d. WFT Est. 1866-1939; m. CLEMENTINE HENSLEY, WFT Est. 1866-1899. xi. HENRIETTA OBENSHAIN, b. October 24, 1852; d. WFT Est. 1866-1946; m. RANDLE FERGUSON, WFT Est. 1866-1899. xii. VIRGINIA OBENSHAIN, b. August 15, 1858; d. WFT Est. 1872-1952; m. ANDREW NOFSINGER, WFT Est. 1872-1905. xiii. SAMUEL C. OBENSHAIN, b. WFT Est. 1825-1854; d. WFT Est. 1831-1933.