Hi, Jeanne, Although this was not what you requested, perhaps it might help, particularly if someone else reads this who has another piece of the puzzle. From a book listing marriages in Harrison County, a David CALDWELL m. Eunice CLARK on Aug 12, 1801. Eunice was the dau. of Joshua CLARK. Then on 1/6/1826 a Martha Caldwell dau. of Eunice m. John MOUNTS. It would appear that David had died by 1826. Also, on 3/8/1826 Joshua "Calwill" [indexed as Caldwell] m. Hannah SAERE dau. of Jedediah and Elizabeth. These are the only Caldwell marriages, recorded in the County Courthouse, which took place in Harrison County in the first half of the 1800's. I've found that if two or more children in one family marry and if only a mother is listed as the parent of a woman, that it is very likely that the father died within the previous year. In Earl Core's Vol. I there is mention of a Joseph CALDWELL and a cert. for 400 acres on the Mon. River including his settlement there in 1771. Core adds that this was at the mouth of Indian Camp Run in Harrison County. Then Core writes that this Joseph may have been a brother in law of James CHEW or that this tract may have been in Fayette County [PA].. That's a puzzling comment! He references Vol. 3 of Horn, the map book, map 19. Another possible source for information would be to join the Harrison County Gen. Society which also has a list: [email protected] Hope this leads to something for you! Regards, Jane ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Jane McCann Walsh [email protected]