* Prime's History of Lo,r~~ Is/and arid the Horton Genealoqy. t Pcdi~-ree of Kuh.f, of Salem. MSS. Record of Stuart Tuthill Terry. 6. viii. DANIEL, b. 23 Jan., 1679. ix. NATHANIEL, b. 10 Nov., 1683 ; d. at Antigua, W. I., 18 Dec., 1705. X. MARY (daughter of 2nd wife), d, i i Jan., 1698/9 aged about 8 years. 4. John TUTHILL (John', Henry', Henry',), of Southold, b. 14 Feb., 8; d. 21 Nov., 1754 m. Mehirable' Wells ( Win.'), b. at 1666 m. in, or before 1683; d. 26 Aug., 1742. John was a landowner in South: old Town, Justice of the Peace, Commissioner to lay out the King's Highway (the first public road from Brooklyn to Easthampton), Member of the N. Y. Provincial Assembly from 169398, and Sheriff. Children, all natives of Southold Town, perhaps not in order: 7. i. JOHN', b. in 1683. III. MARY, b. 1687 ; d. in 1780, aged 93 m. 27 Nov., i 1706/7 Joan-than' Horton (Capt. Jonathan', Barnabas'), of Southold, b. 23 Dec., 1683 ; d. 2 April, 1768. They had six children Mary', Elzphaz, Mehi~'able, Azariah, Lasarus, and Ambrose Horton, born between 170820. Of these, Azariab, a graduate of Yale College, was missionary to the I.. I. In-dians, and ancestor of the Rev. Theodore L. Cuyler, of Brooklyn,* while Lazarus Horton, b. 1717, m. Ann Corey (David', Isaac', John'). 9. iv. JOSHUA, b. in 1690. Y. DOROTHY, b. perhaps in 1692 ; m. Joseph Brown, of Southold (possibly son of Walter [see Census of 1698], or of Joseph Brown, Sr., whose death on the II Dec., 1739, is recorded in the Salmon Record), b. probably before 1698 ; d. 14 July, 1751. His will (L. 17, p. 412, New York City Wills) mentions "Wife Dorothy, Brother Daniel Brown, Live sons; married, and unmarried 'daughters," naming but one of the latter, Dorothy. Issue; order unknown : Dorothy', Han-nah, Benjamin, Joseph, Joshua, SeIah, Jeremiah, and Abigail Brown. This last, probably b. 173437 ; d. before 1770. She was the 1st wife of John' King, Jr. (John', Saint.', Saint.', Win.'), of Southold, b. iS Dec., 1727 ; m. '3 March, ; d. 14 July, 1792.t 10. vi. DANIEL. 11. vii. FREEGIFT, b. 8 Aug., 1698. vill. HANNAH (perhaps), either she, or her niece, Hannah, daugh-ter of John Tuthill, No, ~, m. Noah Tuthill, in 1738. ~. HENRY' TUTHILL (John', Henry', Henry'), of Southold. b. i May, z66~ d. Jan., 1750 ; m. before 16904 Bethia' Horton ( Cap:. Jonathan' Barnabas'), b. at 1674 : d. r6 March, 1744. Henry was Justice of the Peace, and owned land in the Towns of Southold and Brookhaven, The subject of the marriage date of Henry and Bethia is discussed in Keith's Ancestry of Benj~amin Harriron, The daughter Rebecca attributed to Henry, in Moore's Indexes of Southold Genealogies, is doubtless only an error of type, as Henry's will (Lib. 17, p. ii8, N. Y. City Wills) cited as authority, does not contain the word Rebecca. Issue, all ol Southold Town: 12. I. HENRY', b. in 1690. 11. JONATHAN, b. in 169*; d. 8 Feb., 1741 ; m. 23 Feb., x723 Susannah L'Hommedieu, who died his widow, 17 May 1743, in her 39th year. She was the daughter of Benjamin and Patience (Sylvester) L'Hommedieu, of Southold, and the granddaughter of Thomas Brinley, Esq., of Stafford-shire, England, auditor of King Charles Ist.* Issue, all of the Town of Southold: i. Jonathan', d. 25 Feb., I72~, aged 2 years. 2. Benlamin (doubtless), who d. i6 Feb., I74~, in his 23rd year ; he is buried near Susannah and Jonathan, at Orient. 3. Beihia, mentioned in the will of her grandfather, Henry Tuthill. III. NATHANIEL, b. about 1694, drowned at sea, 27 April, 1727, probably m. Mary Petty, 4 Oct., 1721. He, or his brother Barnabas, was doubtless the father of John' Tuth ill and De-liverance, wife of Elisha Paine, named by Henry Tuthill, as his grandchildren, in his will, quoted above. Iv. BARNABAS, b. perhaps in 1696, certainly before 1698. It is still an open question whether this man be Major Barnabas Tuthill, or not. The weight of authority being against it, see Barnabas, the probable son of Henry, No. 12.t v. BETHIA, b. 12 Dec., 1703 ; d. 30 Aug., ,761 ; m. 26 May, 1721. She was the ist wife of Samuel' Landon (.Nizthan) of Southold; b. there, 20 May, 1699; d. at Guilford, Conn., 21 Jan.. 1782. Issue, ten children: Henry',daughter, Han-nizh, Samuel, Bethia, Parnel, Nathaniel, fared, David, and jonathan Landon, born in Southold, between 1741743. * Magazine of American lli.rtory. Nov., 1887, p. 361. t A Partial Record o/ the Landons, of Southold, "N. V. Gen. and Biog. Rec.," Jan., 1897. MAJOR BARNABAS TUTHILLMoore's Indexes" stale that Barnabas (ion of Henry Tulbill, b. 166~), d. in 178, that he m. ISI, Lydia King in '759, who d. in 1779 ; and 2nd, Annie King in 1780. The census of 1698 shows that Henry's son Barnabas was then alive, while the Salmon Record" assigns the above wives to Major Barnabas Tuthill, but Griflin'~ "Journal" places Major Barnabas, as son of Henry, b. 1690, and grandson of Henry, b. 1665. How are we to decide the parentage of Ilte said major? Again, Moore's "In-dexes" do not assign any son Baritabas to Henry, . s6qo. One thing is certainthe Barnabas Tuthill, given in the Southold militia, in the Report of the New York State Historian for 1897, as serving in 1715, was tite son of Henry. b. 1665, for if Henry, b. r6qo, had a son named Barnabas. he was b. after 1717. Were there, how-ever, two Barnabas Tuthills, or only one? Which one served ri the French war in 1759 and which as a major in the American Revolution Judge Tuthill, of Iowa, believed Major Barnabas to be son of Henry Tulhill. b. 1690. An old record from Orient gives the following : " Children of Major Barnabas Tuthill: 1st son, Barnabas, m. Desish Conklin, d. Nov., 1805 2nd son, Gamaliel, m. Milliken 3d son, Samuel 4th, Joshita. 1st dau., Lydia m. John Paine 2nd dau., Hannah, m. a Thompkins, oC Orange Co. 3rd dan., Lucrecia, m. a Thomp. kins, of Orange Co. Charlie Griffith cgriff@ccomm.com