According to "Tuttle and Tuthill Lines in America" by Alva Tuttle, Ara was a son of Clement. Alva references "History of Ashtabula County, Ohio, 1878", and lists his children as Mary, born July 20, 1813; Maria, born May 21, 1815; Asahel born June 4, 1817; Lucius, born October 11 1819; Uriel, born July 10, 1821; Lewis, born April 21, 1823; Martha, born September 2, 1825, Clement, born July 9, 1827; John, died at age 14, Denmark, IA; Jas H., born Jun 1833; Sarah, born 1835; Benj., born c 1837; Persis M., born c 1839. I'm looking for a Oliver A. Tuttle. born abt. 1823 who died Ashtabula County, Ohio. Do you know if he could be Clement's son? Janice