Barbara, MF and Syntha father was Rev Hugh. Rev Hughs mother was Lucreatia.The lineage goes like this. Hugh Caldwell B 1740 D 1819 M Rutha Holstien 1763 there 8th child Hugh Hugh Caldwell B M Nancy Ferrier Botetourt VA 1809 Moved to Knox Co M Lucretia Gault Welch TN 1825 Hugh and Nancy 1st child English Caldwell d 1848 murdered at Graveston Tn Hugh and Lucretia 1st child Hugh b 1827 Became the Rev Hugh Caldwell Rev Hugh Caldwell b 1/20/27 d 6/5/1906 M 1st Polly Bayless d1876 M 2nd minerva Hoskins d1900 Rev Hugh Caldwells children were MF Caldwell(Millard) Mary, Evie, Winfield (MD) Syntha, Betty. Syntha was married 2 times 1st Stanley 2nd Hill . Millard was a Attorney with the Knoxville Bar later a US Congressman and Gov of Florida. All of Hugh Caldwell and Lucretia Gault Welch Caldwell children were Minerva, Malinda, Eunice, Sarah, George, Hugh(Rev ) Rhoda Melvinia, William, Thomas. Thomas died during the Civil War He married Lydia Kirkpatrick and had 2 sons. Lydia died and he later married her sister Mary Ann, Both were daughters of Robert and Rachel Bayless Kirkpatrick. His to sons were Marion and Hugh Hugh and Nancy Caldwell had the folowing children English , Robert,Rutha,Mary . I hope this clears up any confusion from my earlier message. If you need any other info let me know. Cordially, Mark Caldwell