RootsWeb.com Mailing Lists
Total: 1/1
    1. [TNROANE] More on Publications
    2. P McDonald
    3. While on this general subject, I would like to address a sore subjct. If you find a web site, message board, book, or other publication, or receive an E-mail from someone with family information in it, there is an implied copyright on that material. If you want to copy parts of the data into your database, it would be common courtesy to contact the author for permission, and to definitely show your source in anything you pass along. I have found Notes copied word for word from my web site plastered all over Rootsweb trees and other web sites, and I feel sure they have been submitted to World Family Tree CDs for commercial use. I have seen Notes that have included contents of E-mails that I am pretty sure came from Marj Watts, a professional researcher, for instance. Many, many sites have blurbs that I feel sure came from the Roane Heritage site, with no credits. It is true that noone has ownership of ancestors, or a list of ancestors. But some people have put a lot of time and effort into abstracting court records, interviewing elderly people, ferreting out Bible records and photographs, and then compiling the information into concise form. And we are are most grateful for that work. Most of these people are happy to share with individuals who just want to more about their family. But copying and posting such compiled data to a book or web site, for instance, is plagariasm. Rootsweb has rules about not using something one doesn't own, and the National Genelogical Society has Guidelines treating this subject that we all should review from time to time. Every How-to genealogy instruction I've ever seen emphasises the need for recording Source. On top of everything else, sometimes people blindly copy information that is wrong--perpetuating old "myths." That does not help anyone, although it might give bragging rights to those who want to say they have X thousand names in their file. Bottom line: If you didn't write it, it ain't yours! And besides, you lose credibility when others find out where you got it and didn't bother to check further. Pat McDonald

    11/23/2002 03:30:28