There is an error in the 1860 Giles Co TN census: 115/115 Wm C Massey should be Wm C Poarch, 36 (b Nov 20 1822) Farmer Massey is Lucinda's maiden name Lucinda C 25 (Lucinda Caroline Massey Poarch b Dec 27 1830) Mary A 12 ( Mary Ann b Dec 28 1852 m A J McGaugh) John 9 (John Massey Poarch b Jan 24 1852) W N 7 (William Newton Poarch b Feb 15 1854) Henry ? 4 (Henry Leroy Poarch b Mar 3 1856) Alonzo 2 (Morgan Alonzo Poarch b May 14 1858) They were living next door to Wm C Sanders and his wife, Mary Ann Poarch Sanders, Wm C Poarch's sister. If you don't agree, please let me know why. I may be wrong, but names and dates fit Wm C Poarch family. Virginia Poarch virginia@isgroup.net