Gosh JW, Think anything is possible, especially since we don't have wills for our ancestors. Most of our Reagan research came from Wilma R. Pinkley, she has a lot of the old records, family bible for John etc. so don't know if she had the actual proof for Caleb or not. Since they usually named their 1st son after their father with Caleb naming his 1st born Peter then it made sense he belonged to Peter Jr. If you really feel Caleb is Joel's will try to help you find the proof. I do think she must have had something though as she knew he had went to Newton Co. MO and had the names of his 2 sons. Will send you John's information on your private e-mail. Pat