John, Thank you for reminding me!! Call it a Senior moment!! Bettie Bird and I are working on this line right now AGAIN!! Every January we get fired up to break this brick wall!!. First of all, Roberts is in my Husband's line. His Grandmother was Hester Slover Luttrell Whaley. Her Mother was Parthenia Roberts who married William H. Slover. Her Mother was Mary Polly Roberts and Father was Albert Beech (recorded on Parthenia's Death Certificate). Parthenia had a Sister Josephine who married John Pebley. I do not know Jospehine's Father. Mary Polly Roberts and Annaliza Roberts, we have thought were children of Wesley Roberts and Arta. We are not sure of this. Do you have any facts to this?? Bettie and I both think we have to go back to North Carolina to prove or disprove it. What do you think?? Bettie is related through Annaliza. Thanks again for reminding me to contact you!! Carolyn Whaley