Ralph: I found Lucy as the daughter of Zebina - it's in the Vital Records of Boylston p. 44. I guess what this all means is that some of my secondary sources, cited in the original message, were confused. It looks to me like the Vital Records information pretty well substantiates the way I had it in the first place. Thanks for the help. Park -- L. Parker Temple Researching the branches of the TEMPLE family See my home page at http://www.erols.com/lptemple/house.htm