This is all the Andrew Taylors in TN in 1880. There were none named as just "Andy". I would assume he had to be 21 to be tried for murder then. but I don't know that for a fact. But I would look at the ones born by 1862. Carleen TAYLOR, Andrew Other <1798> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Shelby District10 TAYLOR, Andrew J. Self <1820> M W Bir: NC Cen: TN Willia District12 TAYLOR, Andrew J. Self <1821> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Humphr District14 TYLER, Andrew Self <1826> M W Bir: ENGL Cen: TN Davids Nashville TAYLOR, Andrew Self <1828> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Carter StoneyCree TAYLOR, Andrew J. Self <1832> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Blount District13 TAYLOR, Andrew Self <1842> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Madiso District6 TAYLOR, Andrew J. Self <1843> M W Bir: NC Cen: TN Wilson District10 TAYLOR, Andrew H. Brother <1846> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Blount District1 TAYLOR, Andrew M. Son <1847> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Frankl District14 TAYLOR, Andrew T. Brother <1854> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Marion Jasper TAYLOR, A. Andrew Self <1855> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Weakle SharoStati TAYLOR, Andrew Self <1857> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Weakle MartinStor TAYLOR, Andrew H. Son <1858> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Coffee District6 TAYLOR, Andrew SonL <1858> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Weakle GardneStor TAYLOR, Andrew I. Son <1860> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Overto District13 TAYLOR, Andrew Other <1860> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Roane District16 TAYLOR, Andrew Other <1861> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Madiso District16 TAYLOR, Andrew Son <1862> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Bradle District12 TALER, Andru Son <1862> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Jeffer District12 TAYLOR, Andrew Son <1862> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Lincol District23 TAYLOR, Andy Other <1863> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Roane Rockwood TAYLOR, Andrew Son <1864> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Johnso District3 TAYLOR, Andrew Other <1864> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Morgan Wartburg TAYLOR, Andrew Uncle <1864> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Obion KentoStati TAYLOR, Andrew Son <1864> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Overto District12 TAYLOR, Andrew J. Son <1864> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Stewar SaliTobaPo TAYLOR, Andrew J. Son <1864> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Stewar SaliTobaPo TAYLOR, Andrew Brother <1865> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Knox District19 TAYLOR, Andrew K. Son <1866> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Carter BuffalCree TAYLOR, Andrew J. Son <1866> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Coffee District11 TAYLOR, Andrew S. Son <1866> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Haywoo District5 TAYLOR, Andrew Son <1867> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Cocke IrishBotto TAYLOR, Andrew Son <1868> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Ruther District20 TAYLOR, Andrew Son <1869> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Carter Taylortown TAYLOR, Andrew Son <1869> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Greene District17 TAYLOR, Andrew J. BroL <1872> M W Bir: KY Cen: TN Campbe LowerElk TYLER, Andrew N. Son <1872> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Crocke BellsDepot TAYLOR, Andrew J. Son <1875> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Blount District13 TAYLOR, Andrew J. Son <1875> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Perry District6 TAYLOR, Andy Son <1876> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Cumber District5 TAYLOR, Andrew J. Son <1877> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Cannon District5 TYLER, Andrew H. Son <1877> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Coffee District17 TAYLOR, Andy Son <1878> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Lincol District4 TAYLOR, Andrew Son <1878> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN Madiso District6 TAYLOR, Andrew Son <1879> M W Bir: TN Cen: TN DeKalb District10