Gordon writes: My original question was: does any proof exist that would get past a good auditor? The claim that permanent surnames were given for parts played in pageants, etc, seems rather implausible to me. So a supplementary question might be: what were the "scholars" doing offering implausible explanations, with no proof at all, or even evidence? Gordon Barlow ========== I can't help but compare the above to Bible studies and theology. We weren't there and saw nothing but millions believe nevertheless. I think the study of surnames is probably a lot more accurate than the Bible. I can't say with certainty that my father is my father even though I look almost exactly like him. I have my DNA results but not his. According to a recent seminar and series of interviews with biblical scholars, most of whom were rabbis, there was no bondage in Egypt and no Exodus. Most of them don't like to talk about this, especially in temple. It does explain some burning questions that have plagued the religious for many years. Gary