I'm think that the children you listed are actually the children of George Harlan Starr and Nancy or "Nannie" Bell. Caleb Starr and John Bell are the grandfathers of these children. Also, there is another son, Caleb Ellis (b. May 26, 1854). Jim Wilson wrote: > While going through some of my notes, i cam accross the following! > > Caleb Starr m. Bell > > children were: > > James b. 1830 > William K. b. 1835 > Charlotte b. 1840 > John W. b. 1842 > Mary Francis b. 1844 > George Calvin b. 1847 > Ezekiel b. 1849, d. 1905 > Joseph J. b. 1851, d. 1872 > Samuel J., b. 1857, d. listed as still living! > > Cherokee Application form, sent by Pat Smith nee White Baffulo Woman, NA > resercher, Dept. Emmigrat Roll, taken in 1851, pd. @ Fort Gibson! > > Carol Ann,