This is a Message Board Post that is gatewayed to this mailing list. Classification: Query Message Board URL: http://boards.ancestry.com/mbexec/msg/an/VJIBAEB/28295.1 Message Board Post: 1920 census shows James's mother, Harriet in his household, born abt, 1837 in OH. Using that info, I find then in 1860 in Monroe, Richland, OH. Household: Phillip 30 GER Harriet 23 OH James 2 OH Florence 4 mos. OH 1850 shows Phillip in Worthington, Richland, OH with his parents and siblings. Household: Henry C. 48 GER Elizabeth 46 GER Phillip 20 GER Louisa 17 OH Elizabeth 15 OH Frederick 14 OH Jonathan 12 OH George 2 OH This means Phillip couldn't have been more than 3 when he immigrated.