Hi Jim Shot in the dark here. My Phoebe LITTLEJOHN daughter of Abraham LITTLEJOHN and Sarah SHAFFER lived in Clark Co OH during the same time period. Is there a possibility of a relationship there? Abraham and Sarah were married in Berkeley Co VA (W/VA). I have a list of the SHAFFER marriages in Berkeley Co which were posted on the Shaffer list and can be located on Rootsweb by searching the mailing list archive. Judy Hoard