Good job, John. Either would fit. As it happens, John Robson and Jane W. Robson had a daughter named Mary, so I'm favoring your first find. Although either is a possibility and more than I've been able to find. I'm in the process of trying to find their marriage without any luck. Will try Andrew Robson and Margaret Blackburn. My problem is 1837online. I am able to view one or two entries, but not all. Not sure why. Thought it had something to do with the Pop-Up Guard, but changing it didn't seem to help. Any other ideas? You seem to be ahead of me in several areas. Thanks, Judy Dawe