Hi Colin It was a long shot anyway but you contribution was appreciated. There is no great help as far as Andrew's death registration goesIt was completed by his eldest living son William and under parents it says 'Unknown' he listed his father's place of birth as Glasgow and time in Australia as 45 years. 45 years works out to the year Andrew and Jane married 1853 and there is no guarantee it is correct. I put more faith Andrew himself recording his birth place as Greenock than his son who didn't even know the names of his father s parents recording Glasgow as his father's birth place. It is just such a shame I can't find his arrival into Australia. He could have arrived through South Australia which is harder to search. Then again he could even have been a convict. There were a few Andrew Millar's who arrived as convicts from Scotland but none of them stand out as Andrew. No doubt when I least expect it something will turn up. Thanks again for your help, Diane