Further to this: Both couples appear in the 1871 Census (thank you Ian) which I think proves that there are two different Duncan McPhails - one marred to Dina and one to Ann 1871 Salen District No : 3 Page No : 4 House No : 18 Locality : No 15 Salen 187150650 McPhail Duncan 48 Head Wheel Wright Argyleshire Torosay McPhail Ann 45 Wife Argyleshire Salen McPhail Lilly 18 Dau Argyleshire Salen McPhail Mary 12 Dau Scholar Argyleshire Salen McPhail Jessie 10 Dau Scholar Argyleshire Salen McPhail Donald 8 Son Scholar Argyleshire Salen McPhail Ann 6 Dau Scholar Argyleshire Salen McPhail Lachlan 4 Son Argyleshire Salen 1871 Iona District No : 1 Page No : 6 House No : 33 Locality : West End 187110330 McPhail Duncan 58 Head Farmer of 80 arces which 20 arable employing 4 servants Argyllshire Torosay McPhail Dina 46 Wife Argyllshire Iona McPhail Angus 6 Son Scholar Argyllshire Iona McPhail Flora 2 Dau Argyllshire Iona Noris Thomas 20 Servant Farm Servant Argyllshire Kilfinichen Beaton Neil 16 Servant Farm Servant Argyllshire Kilfinichen Cameron Ann 17 Servant Dairy maid Argyllshire Kilfinichen Beaton Marion 18 Nurse Nurse Argyllshire Kilfinichen Cameron Mary 20 Servant Servant Argyllshire Kilfinichen On 9/16/2013 12:37 PM, MF wrote: > Ian > > For people who marry more than once, it would be good if all their respective marriages were shown in chronological order (some are, some aren't) > > TNG allows me to sort spouses and children quite easily > > That aside, please take a look at the following non-chronological marriages from Mullgenealogy. Something is blatantly wrong here. > > Duncan is having children with both women at the same time !! :) > > I suspect that Ann McLean's husband is the wrong Duncan (i.e. bad link) > > Also, I cannot find an 1890 death for Duncan (at least not in Iona/Kilfinichen parish, but I did find the following from Kilfinichen Index (Iona back in by this time) > > 1891 MCPHAIL DUNCAN M 80 KILFINICHEN AND KILVICKEON /ARGYLL 542/00 0002 (could his death be Jan 1891) ? > > Duncan MACPHAIL > Birth : > Baptised : 1 May 1812, Torosay, Isle of Mull, Argyllshire, Scotland > Died : 3 Jan 1890, Isle of Iona, Argyllshire, Scotland > Buried : > Father : Duncan MCPHAIL > Mother : Flora MACKINNON > Marriage 1 : Duncanina [Dunky or Dina] MCCOLL 4 Jun 1863 > Children Angus (bir) 8 Apr 1865 - 27 Nov 1931 > Duncan (bir) 2 Dec 1867 - > Flora Sarah (bir) abt 1869 - > Marriage 2 : Ann MCLEAN 15 Jan 1850 > Children Lily Margaret (bir) abt 1852 - 1923 > Neil (bir) abt 1854 - > Catherine (bir) 11 Oct 1855 - > Mary (bir) 28 Aug 1857 - > Jessie (bir) 24 Jul 1859 - > Donald (bir) 4 May 1861 - > Ann (bir) 20 Jul 1863 - > Lachlan (bir) 7 Dec 1865 - > > > Michael > www.mullfamilies.co.uk > > ------------------------------- > To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to SCT-ISLEOFMULL-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message