Hi Libby: Not sure if you would connect or not since your dates seem to suggest the family stayed in Mull but have you found or made contact with Kim MacMillan ? She has a MacMillan family tree site on myfamily.com and uses Rootsweb, etc. Perhaps a MacMillan connection - there are many MacPhails, MacMillans, McKinnons, etc landing in PEI and Ontario, some both........ Regards Sherri