Hi Karen, Jill and all Re: 1 McArthur Charles 15 Male servant Y b Oct 10 1826 s/o Arthur & Isabel McKinnon could he be the father of Charles who's sons Charles was b Jul 23 1848 that ends up in Dundalk the husband of Catherine Black Indeed Arthur McArthur is how the 1841 census is recorded in my copy. Jean Whimp was going to recheck her original records for it. As Jill had mentioned all birth/christeninngs are recorded as Alexander & Isabel McKinnon. In my own db I have the family listed as Ardalanish 21 McArthur Arthur/Alexander 45 Y Ardalanish 21 McArthur Isabella 40 Y McKinnon m Feb 2 1815 Ardalanish 21 McArthur John 20 Y Mar 9 1818 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Catherine 20 Y Jun 8-10 1820 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Hector 15 Y Sep 20 1822 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Malcolm 15 Y Jan 25 1825 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Mary 12 Y Jul 16 1828 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Murdoch 10 Y Nov 23 1830 Ardalanish 21` McArthur Ann 7 Y 1834 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Lachan 5 Y Jul 12 1835 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Flora 2 Y 1838 Ardalanish 21 McGilvra Donald 20 Tailor Y Ardalanish 21 McEachern Duncan 15 Tailor Apprentice Y Hope this helps clarify the info. Ida

Hi Ida, Yes I did check and sent it in HTML (chart form) to Jill to check all the McArthurs and just confirmed Ians record. Jean -----Original Message----- From: sct-isleofmull-bounces@rootsweb.com [mailto:sct-isleofmull-bounces@rootsweb.com] On Behalf Of Merle & Ida King Sent: Saturday, 24 March 2007 1:28 AM To: roger&karenReede; SCT-ISLEOFMULL Subject: Re: [SCT-ISLEOFMULL] Arthur or Alexander McArthur? Hi Karen, Jill and all Re: 1 McArthur Charles 15 Male servant Y b Oct 10 1826 s/o Arthur & Isabel McKinnon could he be the father of Charles who's sons Charles was b Jul 23 1848 that ends up in Dundalk the husband of Catherine Black Indeed Arthur McArthur is how the 1841 census is recorded in my copy. Jean Whimp was going to recheck her original records for it. As Jill had mentioned all birth/christeninngs are recorded as Alexander & Isabel McKinnon. In my own db I have the family listed as Ardalanish 21 McArthur Arthur/Alexander 45 Y Ardalanish 21 McArthur Isabella 40 Y McKinnon m Feb 2 1815 Ardalanish 21 McArthur John 20 Y Mar 9 1818 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Catherine 20 Y Jun 8-10 1820 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Hector 15 Y Sep 20 1822 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Malcolm 15 Y Jan 25 1825 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Mary 12 Y Jul 16 1828 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Murdoch 10 Y Nov 23 1830 Ardalanish 21` McArthur Ann 7 Y 1834 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Lachan 5 Y Jul 12 1835 Ardalanish 21 McArthur Flora 2 Y 1838 Ardalanish 21 McGilvra Donald 20 Tailor Y Ardalanish 21 McEachern Duncan 15 Tailor Apprentice Y Hope this helps clarify the info. Ida ------------------------------- To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to SCT-ISLEOFMULL-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message

Hi Jean, Jill and Karen Thanks Jean for rechecking your records. I'm sure it was an enumerators error. I'm sure if anyone is taking a peek at the original 1841 census film for Ardalnish KLF they'll let us know. later Ida > >Ardalanish 21 McArthur Arthur/Alexander 45 Y >Ardalanish 21 McArthur Isabella 40 Y >McKinnon m Feb 2 1815 >Ardalanish 21 McArthur John 20 Y Mar 9 1818 >Ardalanish 21 McArthur Catherine 20 Y Jun >8-10 1820 >Ardalanish 21 McArthur Hector 15 Y Sep 20 1822 >Ardalanish 21 McArthur Malcolm 15 Y Jan 25 >1825 >Ardalanish 21 McArthur Mary 12 Y Jul 16 1828 >Ardalanish 21 McArthur Murdoch 10 Y Nov 23 >1830 >Ardalanish 21` McArthur Ann 7 Y 1834 >Ardalanish 21 McArthur Lachan 5 Y Jul 12 1835 >Ardalanish 21 McArthur Flora 2 Y 1838 >Ardalanish 21 McGilvra Donald 20 Tailor Y >Ardalanish 21 McEachern Duncan 15 Tailor >Apprentice Y >