I hope there is not the same confusion in this Marion McNeil as I have one too who is born in Calliach 9 Dec 1795 and I don't know anymore about her. I think she is a sister to my Catherine and I notice there is a marriage of a Marion McNeil, Calliach to an Allan McPhaiden 18 Mar 1817 maybe this marriage is for your Marion as the children don't seem to connect with names of mine. Sorry to confuse the issue again. Jacqueline in N.S. ----- Original Message ----- From: "Merle & Ida King" <m_iking@telusplanet.net> To: <sct-isleofmull@rootsweb.com> Sent: Tuesday, November 27, 2007 11:53 AM Subject: Re: [SCT-ISLEOFMULL] McNeil/Campbell > Hi John > > No connection here but your helping me with my census project. So thank > you. Now that you and Jacqueline have decided which Catherine your each > taking. I can offer this. > > Descendants of Malcolm McNeil > > > 1 Malcolm McNeil b: Bef. 1764 > > .. +Janet Campbell b: Bef. 1764 m: March 16, 1784 in > Caillioch KLN 6934229, 59 d: Bef. November 3, 1799 birth registry > for daughter Janet mother listed as deceased Janet Campbell > . 2 Mary McNeil b: December 14, 1788 in Caillioch KLN > d: December 25, 1867 in Penmore KLN, 1841 Penmore in Mary McLucais/Neil > Ferguson h/h as v Burial: 1861 Aird KLN as house keeper in b-i-l > Duncan McDougall's h/h > ..... +Hugh McGilvra Can't find hide nor hair of him so he > might have died bef 1841 > . 2 Catherine McNeil b: April 22, 1791 in Caillioch KLN > 7005126, 31 family traveled to Australia John Beaton > jcbeaton@bigpond.com > > ..... +Archibald Beaton b: Abt. 1793 m: May 2, 1814 in > Frackdale Kilninian M115442, 0943 > ..... 3 John Beaton b: March 12, 1815 in Frackdale KLN > d: 1882 in To Australia > ......... +? m: 1843 > > ..... 3 Archibald Beaton b: March 2, 1817 in Balligown KLN > d: 1886 in Queensland Australia Burial: To Australia > . 2 Neil McNeil b: June 14, 1795 in Caillioch KLN > > > . 2 Marion McNeil b: November 3, 1797 in Caillioch KLN > > > . 2 Janet McNeil b: November 3, 1799 in Cailloch KLN > d: Bef. 1851 > > ..... +Duncan McDougall b: 1801 in 1841 as McLucais, 1851 > Penmore KLN #10 & 42, 1861 Aird KLN informant on s-i-l Mary's death > Might be gd ch > > ..... 3 John McDougall b: 1830 > > ..... 3 Donald McDougall b: 1831 > > > Then to add more ?'s to the mix. As Janet Campbell died bef Nov 3 1799 > could your Malcolm have remarried to Ann McDonald and had Catherine > 1802, John 1804, Neil 1806, Charles 1808, and Marion/Sarah in 1810 > > Then I wonder if Mary McNeil in 1841 Penmore KLN in Mary McLucash who's > husband was Neil Ferguson (he d Jan 8 1837 burial in Calgary cemetery) > might have some relationship with Duncan McDougall/McLucais/McLucash etc > :-) > > Ida > > John Beaton wrote: > >>Now that we have 'agreed' on sorting out the two Catherine McNeils, I >>would like to ask if anyone on the list (apart from me) has a connection >>to, or information on, the Malcolm McNeil / Janet Campbell family. >> >>>From the OPR we know that Malcolm and Janet married at Caillioch on 16 >>>Mar 1784 and also that Catherine (1791) who married Archibald Beaton had >>>siblings Mary (1788), Neil (1795), Marion (1797) and Janet (1799). All >>>were baptised at Caillioch. From somewhere, but not sure where, I have >>>noted that Mary died in 1867 at Penmore. >> >>Does anyone know anything of these siblings? >> >>John Beaton >>Brisbane >> > > > > ------------------------------- > To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to > SCT-ISLEOFMULL-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without > the quotes in the subject and the body of the message