I am interested in this also as Archibald McDougall m Lily MacKillop 6 May 1811 Torosay..  Marriage as McLullich in Kilpatrick.  I am thinking that he relates to my McDougall who were also sometimes transcribed as McLullich in Torosay late 1700s early 1800s ....... Meanwhile  - worth exploring perhaps......McKillop or MCGILP Duncan McDougall and Mary Buchanan m in 1817 had a son Allan b25 Apr 1824, Drumfin, Isle of Mull, Argyllshire, Scotland Now in 1851 in Row Dunbarton there is a Mary b to Allan Mcdougall,​ Flora Mcgilp. name:Mary Mcdougall gender:Female baptism/christening date:01 Jan 1852 baptism/christening place:ROW,DUNBARTON,SCOTLAND birth date:02 Nov 1851 father's name:Allan Mcdougall mother's name:Flora Mcgilp indexing project (batch) number:C11503-4 system origin:Scotland-ODM source film number:unknown They married in  18 October 1850 Row Dunbartonshire  (banns poss also at Inchinnan,Renfrew,Scotland 12 Oct 1850) 1851 Census shows Allan McDougall 24 and Flora McGilp 22 as both born in Mull  living in Row. her maiden name given. Piece: SCT1851/503 Place: Row -Dunbartonshire Enumeration District: 6 Folio: 593 Page: 8 Schedule: 26 He a Ploughman.  1841 on the mullgenealogy site is Flora McGilp aged 14   1841 Kilfinichen & Kilvicheon District No : 7   Page No : 12   House No : 49   Locality : Kinloch 18412382 Allan could have been an agric worker 1841 at Ardnacroft.Salen  aged 15 1841 Salen District : 3   Page No : 3   House No : 12   Locality : Ardnacroft 18415093 and poss his parents also in Salen  1841 Salen District : 3   Page No : 5   House No : 24   Locality : Kentalen 18415105 This all needs checking out of course but looks possible. I didn't find a birth for Duncan c 1855!!!!  Tricia (MacDougall g'mother) ________________________________ From: Ted Mills <[email protected]> To: [email protected] Sent: Saturday, 5 November, 2011 15:32:32 Subject: [SCT-ISLEOFMULL] McDougal-McKillop marriage As a new person on this list, I am asking whether anyone knows of the Allan McDougald - Flora McKillop marriage on the Isle of Mull, sometime prior to 1853.  They appear on the 1871 census of Elderslie, Bruce, Ontario, aged 48 and 43 respectively, with a note that their two oldest children (Mary and Duncan) were born in Scotland and their third child (Ann 14) was born in Ontario.  This suggests immigration to Canada about 1856.  Their daughter, Mary Jane, 22 years old, married Andrew Hamilton in Greenock, Bruce, Ontario in 1874, and at that time Mary Jane reported her birthplace as "Island of Mull, Scotland." In Elderslie, in 1871, this Allan and Flora were living next door to Murdoch McDougall and Mary (McDougall) McDougall, aged 42 and 23 respectively, and we suspect they may have been related, in spite of the different surname spellings used.  (My goal is actually to trace this Murdoch and Mary back into their Scottish roots, since a living male descendant's yDNA is nearly identical to that of men in my mother's family.) The names of Allan, Flora, and Mary Jane appear on the Mull Genealogy Surname Index but without further data.  An Allan McDougall-Flora McKillop family  appears  in the 1841 Scottish census for Kilninian/Kilmore but with a different listing of children and earlier birthdates than the couple I am seeking, so I think they are not the same people. If any of this sounds familiar, I would appreciate a reply. Ted Mills [email protected]