Ann: I would suggest you take the information in the IGI as a clue rather than fact. Does Archibald also appear in the Scottish Church Records CD with the same dates and parents? I would also suggest you search using some of the BORTHWICK surname variants (BORTHWICK BARTHWICK BOIRTHUIK BOIRTHVIK BORCHTWIK BORTHEIK BORTHEK BORTHEWYK BORTHIK BORTHOCK BORTHUIK BORTHUYK BORTHUYKE BORTHVIC BORTHVIK BORTHWEKE BORTHWIC BORTHWIK BORTHWIKE BORTHWYK BORTHWYKE BORTHYK BORTYK BROTHVIK BOTHWICK). My BORTHWICKs show up as BOTHWICKs. On my web page I have an incomplete, but searchable database of Scottish surname variants. Richard Robertson richrob4@home.com http://members.home.net/richrob4/index.htm