In a message dated 01/30/2000 2:33:44 PM Eastern Standard Time, Rcmjr@aol.com writes: << The exceptions to using flawed material as guides, of course, would be in the cases of known genealogical forgeries (and there are some famous ones) and these might be best dismissed or discredited by this Society or that. So, can you tell us what category the Rembert book fits in and what the specific objections of The Huguenot Society of South Carolina are. >> Greetings from SC. I personally knew L. A. "Brooks" McCall before his death, and I can assure you that any work he was involved with was not a forgery ! URQ