Suzanne, the only dates I have are that William S. Holtzclaw died ca.1862-1869 and that Elizabeth Billings Holtzclaw was born November 1834. These dates are found in the census records, probate records #2445 Spartanburg Co. SC. Listed as there children are Mary Frances Holtzclaw, Emily Fredonia Holtzclaw (both of whom were married to John Q. McCravy) and George R. Holtzclaw (born Feb 1860), and Eliza J. Holtzclaw. John