In a message dated 7/24/01 6:51:23 AM Pacific Daylight Time, mundenal@home.com writes: > Hi Jo, > My theory about Maranda is that she is the daughter of Phillip > Luper (Lupo) found in the 1850 census. I don't know why she would have been > listed with that family unless she was visiting and there was a slip up by > the census taker. She's listed as Caroline and is the right age (more or > less) to be the one married to James Price. Al, I'm starting to think there are 2 Carolines. Caroline Luper who is obviously with Philip Luper's family in the 1850 census and the Caroline who is actually married to James Price in the 1850 census. They are the same age, but if they were the same person, why would they show her in Philip's family when she's obviously been married for over 5 years to James Price. She has 3 children ages 5, 4, 1 in the 1850 census. I think they must be 2 separate Carolines. Cathy